No operating agreement in New York? Here’s what state law decides for your LLC.
Written by Karam Nahas, Esq., The BattleTested Lawyer™
New York’s LLC Law says members shall adopt a written operating agreement; without one, its defaults decide. Three surprise owners: a member can’t withdraw before the LLC dissolves and winds up; a majority in interest can amend the agreement, though some changes need each hurt member’s consent; and a majority in interest of the other members can admit a buyer.
What New York law decides when you have no operating agreement
| The question | What the law says |
|---|---|
| Is an operating agreement required? | Yes. The Law says members shall adopt a written one. The full answerYes, on paper. New York’s LLC Law says the members "shall adopt" a written operating agreement, and it may be made before, when or within 90 days after the articles of organization are filed. The Law defines an operating agreement as a written agreement of the members, so an oral understanding doesn’t fit that definition. Section 417 states no penalty for not adopting one. Where there is no agreement, or it is silent, the Law’s defaults apply; many of its rules begin "except as provided in the operating agreement." Source: N.Y. LLC Law § 417(a); N.Y. LLC Law § 417(c); N.Y. LLC Law § 102(u) |
| Who runs the LLC by default? | The members, unless the articles of organization provide for managers. The full answerThe members. A New York LLC is managed by its members unless its articles of organization provide for management by managers. The switch is keyed to the articles, not the operating agreement, though the operating agreement can grant or withhold particular members’ management powers. In a member-managed LLC, every member is an agent of the company for ordinary-course business, and a member exercising management powers is treated as a manager, with a manager’s duty of good faith and care. Source: N.Y. LLC Law § 401(a)-(b); N.Y. LLC Law § 412(a); N.Y. LLC Law § 409(a) |
| How do votes count? | By profit share: a majority in interest decides, even to amend the operating agreement. The full answerVotes go by ownership: each member votes in proportion to that member’s share of current profits, and with no agreement, profits follow the value of each member’s unreturned contributions as stated in the company’s records. A majority in interest, meaning members with more than half of the profit shares, is the default to admit a new member, take on debt outside the ordinary course, amend the articles or the operating agreement, dissolve, sell all or substantially all assets, or merge. There are limits: an amendment that raises a member’s contribution obligation, changes tax allocations, changes how distributions are figured or lets a contribution obligation be compromised by less than every member needs the written consent of each member it adversely affects, and a rule that requires a set percentage to vote can’t be amended by fewer than that percentage. By default the LLC holds annual members’ meetings, and a majority in interest is a quorum. An LLC whose original articles took effect before § 402’s current text follows the earlier version. |
| How is money split? | By value of unreturned contributions, not equal shares. The full answerPayouts are shared by the value, as stated in the company’s records, of each member’s contributions received or promised and not returned, not in equal shares. Contribution promises in default don’t count. Profits and losses follow the same rule. Contributions can be cash, property, services or a promise of any of these, so their value can become the fight. Section 507 ties a member’s right to payouts before withdrawal or dissolution to the times or events the operating agreement specifies. At wind-up, creditors come first, then payouts already owed to members and former members, then unreturned contributions, and the rest follows the members’ distribution shares. Source: N.Y. LLC Law § 504; N.Y. LLC Law § 503; N.Y. LLC Law § 501; N.Y. LLC Law § 507; N.Y. LLC Law § 704 |
| Can a member quit, and does the LLC have to buy them out? | No. A member can’t withdraw before dissolution unless the agreement allows it. The full answerUnless an operating agreement provides otherwise, a member may not withdraw from a New York LLC before it dissolves and winds up; a member may withdraw only at the times or on the events the operating agreement specifies. If the agreement allows withdrawal but doesn’t say what the member receives, the withdrawing member is entitled, within a reasonable time, to the fair value of the membership interest as of the withdrawal date, based on the member’s right to share in distributions. A member can still assign the interest, and a member who assigns all of it ceases to be a member. LLCs whose original articles took effect before § 606’s current text follow the earlier version. Source: N.Y. LLC Law § 606(a)-(b); N.Y. LLC Law § 509; N.Y. LLC Law § 603(a)(4) |
| What happens when a member dies or becomes incapacitated? | The representative can act to settle the estate; the others have 180 days to vote to dissolve. The full answerIf a member dies or a court adjudges the member incompetent, the member’s executor, administrator, guardian, conservator or other legal representative may exercise all of the member’s rights to settle the estate or administer the member’s property, including any power the operating agreement gives an assignee to become a member. The Law treats death as an event that ends membership. It does not dissolve the LLC, but within 180 days a majority in interest of the remaining members can vote or agree in writing to dissolve it. If the last remaining member’s membership ends, the LLC dissolves unless, within 180 days, that member’s legal representative agrees in writing to continue it and to the admission of the representative or an assignee as a member. An LLC whose original articles took effect before § 701’s current text follows the earlier version. Source: N.Y. LLC Law § 608; N.Y. LLC Law § 701(b); N.Y. LLC Law § 701(a)(4); N.Y. LLC Law § 701(c) |
| Can a member sell or give away their share? | Yes, but the buyer gets money rights only, and a majority of the others can admit them. The full answerA membership interest can be assigned in whole or in part. The assignee gets only the distributions and profit-and-loss allocations the member would have received, with no part in management and no member’s rights. The assignee becomes a member with the vote or written consent of a majority in interest of the members other than the one assigning, not every member. A member who assigns the entire interest stops being a member; pledging it as collateral does not have that effect. The assignor stays liable under the Law and the operating agreement, with narrow exceptions. Source: N.Y. LLC Law § 603(a); N.Y. LLC Law § 604(a); N.Y. LLC Law § 605 |
| When does the LLC dissolve, and can one member ask a court to end it? | A majority in interest can dissolve it, and a member can ask a court on one ground. The full answerThe LLC dissolves at a time or on an event set in the articles or operating agreement, by vote or written consent of at least a majority in interest of the members (of each class, if there is more than one), when it has no members (subject to the 180-day continuation rule), or by court decree. With no end date set, it has perpetual existence. A member can ask the Supreme Court in the judicial district where the LLC’s office is located to dissolve it, and the Law states one ground: it is not reasonably practicable to carry on the business in conformity with the articles or operating agreement. Section 702 lists no separate ground for fraud, oppression or deadlock. After a dissolution other than by court decree, the members may wind up, and the court may do it on cause shown. An LLC whose original articles took effect before § 701’s current text follows the earlier version. Source: N.Y. LLC Law § 701(a); N.Y. LLC Law § 702; N.Y. LLC Law § 703(a); N.Y. LLC Law § 701(c) |
Why this matters when someone sues
With no operating agreement, a statute and a judge decide how your LLC works. Nobody sues “to pierce an LLC.” They sue the company and add an alter-ego count against the owner personally, and that count opens the owner’s books in discovery. An operating agreement the owners actually follow, kept with their records, changes that math.
Karam Nahas has seen how much one sentence can carry: a single both-owners-must-agree line in a family LLC’s operating agreement stopped a brother from selling a $5 million building behind his co-owner’s back.
Keeping a New York LLC in good standing
- Biennial Statement: Biennial Statement due every two years in the calendar month in which the LLC's articles of organization were originally filed; do not file before that month. Fee: $9.
- Publication: required. Within 120 days after the articles of organization are filed, publish a notice of formation in two newspapers designated by the county clerk (one daily, one weekly) once a week for six consecutive weeks, then file the Certificate of Publication with the Department of State ($50 filing fee). Failure suspends the LLC's authority to carry on business until cured. Theatrical production LLCs are exempt.
- Registered agent: changing it takes a filing with the state.
Checked with the state’s own sites on October 14, 2026.
Write your own rules
Start with the free LLC playbook, then put the rules in a signed operating agreement built for your state.
Read more
Sources
The statute: New York Limited Liability Company Law (N.Y. LLC Law §§ 101 to 1403)
Facts checked on November 21, 2026
Education, not legal, tax or financial advice. No attorney-client relationship.
Admitted in New Jersey.